The Best Pizza Spots in San Jose California 2024
From gooey, deep-dish pies to thin, crispy New York-style slices, San Jose is home to an appetizing array of top-notch pizza spots to satisfy any craving. If you’re a local searching for a new favorite pizza spot or a visitor looking to grab a quintessential taste of the city, San Jose serves up pizzerias as diverse and creative as Silicon Valley itself. Read on for the inside scoop on the best San Jose pizza spots for families, date night or to grab a slice on the go!
1. Bibo’s NY Pizza
If you find yourself on the south side of town, make your way to Bibo’s NY Pizza for huge, foldable slices just like you’d find on the streets of New York. Their thin crust has a perfectly crisp exterior while maintaining a fluffy interior. Toppings like pepperoni get nicely caramelized from their hot brick ovens.
I like to grab a juicy Italian sandwich while I’m there too because you have to take advantage of that authentic NY deli counter in the back!
Address: 1431 Bird Ave San Jose, CA 95125
2. Slice of New York
Tucked away in a small strip mall on busy Stevens Creek Boulevard, Slice of New York offers classic New York-style pizza by the slice or whole pies to go. They top their pizzas with thin and crispy crusts with typical ingredients like mozzarella, parmesan, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, and onions. In addition to pizza, they also offer wings, salads, and freshly baked rolls. With just a handful of tables inside, Slice of New York is best for picking up food to go.
They sell by the slice, which is pretty rare in San Jose. In the customary fashion of whatever’s on the counter, they’ll take a slice and warm it up. Slice of New York also sells calzones, cannoli, and cheesecake plus they also sell their dough for those who like to make their own pizza at home.
Parking can be tricky in their small lot, but you can usually find street parking nearby. If you want to enjoy your pizza on-site, get your food to go and make the quick walk over to nearby Pritchard Park which offers open grassy areas perfect for a picnic. For no-frills New York-style pizza in San Jose, Slice of New York hits the spot.
Address: 3443 Stevens Creek Blvd San Jose, CA 95117
3. Pizza My Heart
A local favorite for over 20 years, Pizza My Heart serves up good pizza with fun, surf-inspired vibes. This lively sit-down pizzeria is located in a strip mall on Blossom Hill Ave in South San Jose, just look for the maroon surfboard sign. Inside, vibrant murals and an arcade area make it perfect for families and kids. Pizza My Heart offers a full menu of pizzas like the classic pepperoni and cheese along with signature creations like the Pacific Beach piled high with bacon, pineapple and jalapeños.
We like that Pizza My Heart offers pizza by the entire pie and by the slice like Slice of New York that we discussed above.
Parking can get crowded on weekends, but you can usually find a spot in the large parking lot or on the side streets. In addition to pizza, Pizza My Heart also serves up wings, salads, sandwiches, pasta, and desserts like their famous dirt cups.
This place is perfect for birthday parties or just a fun casual night out.
Address: 1390 Lincoln Ave San Jose, CA 95125
4. High Five Pizza
High Five Pizza Company is a pizza establishment and sports bar located in South San Jose. This is a neighborhood favorite and the parlor has been open for over 20 years and they offer local pizza delivery.
Try the “High Five” which is homemade meatballs in a special marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese. Meat lovers will love the “All Meat” which has pepperoni, ground beef, sausage, salami, and linguica.
They also serve hot gourmet sandwiches on a fresh French roll with your choice of macaroni salad, potato salad, or French fries.
Address: 171 Branham Ln, San Jose, CA 95136
5. Willow Street Wood-Fired Pizza
Willow Street Pizza in the Willow Glen neighborhood of San Jose is a popular local pizza chain known for its New York-style thin-crust pizza pies. The restaurant first opened its doors in 1991 and has since expanded to multiple locations across the city, serving up fresh-tasting pizzas in their wood-burning oven. Known for its cozy environment and its chewy crust pizzas, Willow Street Wood-Fired Pizza is a fantastic choice for date night.
The “Garlic Chicken” is a popular pie and comes with garlic cream, mozzarella, parmesan, bacon, spinach, and caramelized onion. Their “BBQ Chicken” pie has BBQ sauce, mozzarella, smoked gouda, red onions, cilantro and is another local favorite. Along with an array of classic and signature pizza options, patrons can also enjoy appetizers like house salads, wings, and garlic bread.
Address: 1072 Willow Street San Jose, CA 95125
Note: parking is tough in this area so use Uber or Lyft to get into the area, especially around the weekends.
6. Paxti’s
If you are looking for deep-dish pizzas, then Paxti’s is the restaurant you are looking for. Paxti’s Pizza is a well-known pizzeria with multiple locations in California, including San Jose. Paxti’s is known for its Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, a style characterized by a thick, buttery crust and layers of cheese and toppings.
We tried the “Special” which is all-natural garlic-fennel sausage, fresh mushrooms, green peppers & white onions. This delicious pizza has a thick crust but a thin bottom and their pizza pies have layers of cheesy goodness. Paxti’s also encourages guests to try honey on their deep-dish pizza crusts for a savory and sweet treat!
Paxti’s also offers thin-crust pizza plus a variety of refreshing salads in addition to offering gluten-free options.
Address: 1875 S Bascom Ave Ste 405 Campbell, CA 95008
7. Pizza Bocca Lupo
Pizza Bocca Lupo is the place to go for pizza lovers who enjoy Neapolitan-style pizza. Tucked away in San Pedro Square in Downtown San Jose, Pizza Bocca Lupo fills a pizza void in the area.
Try the “Joe’s Special” pizza with sausage, mushroom and mozzarella. The catch is the wait time at Pizza Bocca Lupo, if you’re ordering at the restaurant, be prepared for a bit of a delay since they don’t have slices or pies ready to go.
There is plenty of seating, both inside and out, with music and a couple of great bars as well.
Address: 87 N San Pedro St Ste 133 San Jose, CA 95110
8. Cicero’s Pizza
Ciciero’s Pizza is a popular, no-frills, homey, neighborhood pizza spot. It’s very casual, with plenty of seating and most importantly a good pizza! This is not your fancy artisanal pizza with zero flour but it’s great all the same. The crust is uniformly thin and has a nice crispness to it. The marinara sauce is delicious and the pies have the appropriate amount of cheese and fresh ingredients.
Try the “Baker’s Pride” which has tomato sauce, mushrooms, green bell peppers, Italian sausage, and onions.
Address: 6138 Bollinger Rd San Jose, CA 95129
9. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza is a popular fast-casual pizza restaurant chain that was founded in 2012 in Irvine, California by Elise and Rick Wetzel. The concept behind Blaze Pizza is serving artisanal-style personal pizzas very quickly using an assembly line model. Customers at Blaze can choose from several crust options and select from a variety of cheeses, meats, vegetables, and sauces to fully customize their 11-inch personal pizza. Employees then assemble and cook the pizzas in open-flame ovens in just 3 minutes.
We like that guests can either order thick-crust or thin-crust pies. They have a wide variety of fresh produce and you can add things like oil, feta cheese, black olives, fresh tomatoes, arugula, or jalapenos to your pizza. With its efficient service system, high-quality ingredients, reasonable prices, and the ability for customers to create fully personalized pizzas, Blaze Pizza has proven to be enormously successful.
Address: 5353 Almaden Expy San Jose, CA 95118
10. Tony DiMaggio’s Pizza
Tony DiMaggios Pizza is a popular local pizza restaurant located in the Willow Glen neighborhood of San Jose, California. Family-owned and operated since 1991, Tony DiMaggio’s is known for its tasty New York-style pizza baked in a coal oven. Patrons can build their own pizza by choosing from a variety of fresh toppings or selecting one of Tony’s specialty pies.
Popular choices include the classic combo, “Tony’s Combo”, with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, sausage, olives, and green peppers, or the “Tony’s Veggie”, loaded with mushrooms, green peppers, tomatoes, spinach, and artichoke hearts. Tony DiMaggio’s also offers calzones, salads, pasta dishes, and desserts to round out the menu.
With its checkered tablecloths, pictures of Italian landscapes, and Frank Sinatra tunes playing in the background, Tony DiMaggio offers tasty pizza with an authentic Italian dining experience. It’s one of our favorite San Jose pizza spots in the heart of the South Bay.
Address: 3852 Monterey Hwy, San Jose, CA 95111
